nice &mdash 12/02/06 - 03:42:02 PM
its quite enjoyable. my favorite part is the guitars in the beginning. nicely mixed as well. all around good job [ Reply to This ]
guitars &mdash 12/03/06 - 11:01:59 AM
Thanks for stopping by. Shawn's guitar soundscapes are indeed splendid. Glad you liked this.
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
Love it. &mdash 12/02/06 - 04:42:36 PM
thanks &mdash 12/03/06 - 11:04:16 AM
Thanks so much for your time listening and commenting, Dave.
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
.. it shows .. &mdash 12/02/06 - 04:45:26 PM
gets my vote .. this is excellent gothic rock. Reminds me in small places
of "Big in Japan" by Alphaville.. but that's probably just me. Superb
mix and I too loved those guitars. [ Reply to This ]
big in japan... &mdash 12/03/06 - 11:07:46 AM
... that's something belonging to MY yesteryears, hehe. A big thanks for stopping by and for your thoughts, Alan. Always much appreciated. How is your 'oo' project getting along BTW?
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
no problem &mdash 12/04/06 - 01:22:12 AM
.. pleasure was mine. Ah, 'oo' project? Slow .. might need some plugging ..
I've enlisted the Brothers Luper (I think), if I can take "bring it on" as a yes lol ..
sent some Notes to some girls I know - we'll see. I have an improved version/mix if you want me to re-send it to you?
---
"In Swedish, there is a subtle difference between being ugly or drunk" [ Reply to This ]
loved this as well m8 &mdash 12/02/06 - 05:23:46 PM
a song a month? sounds gr8 to me. Walter.....excellent job on your artistry, lyrics and emotion.....an absolute pleasure to work with you....... [ Reply to This ]
likewise &mdash 12/03/06 - 11:15:43 AM
I found this comment (fragment) on AcidPlanet about the song: "...It seems to have an originality that would suggest the two of you have been working together for years...". Dead on, and nothing more to add. Crazy to face that each song doens't take more than three or four e-mails from both sides... But one day we should start 'talking' to each other :-)
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
amazing singing style.. &mdash 12/02/06 - 05:42:18 PM
along with already unique and unidentifiable percussion your vocal in this reflect a spectrum of all different ethnic vocal styles sparkling within your personality...
a great joy to have found this.. thanks for sharing [ Reply to This ]
a pleasure sharing with you &mdash 12/03/06 - 11:19:44 AM
What a poetic comment, Hún. Thanks so much for your beautiful words.
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
Very well &mdash 12/02/06 - 09:25:16 PM
old soul. Great panarama of expression. The delivery of this struck me akindred to ancient celt-norse poem form instructure, intrenched in ultra moderesk goth somber. Totaly cool combo.
If, for me, maybe because of my earing, the voice sounded a little distorded due to antenuation of the mic in a couple of places. But then I listen with dynasour ears and all is not as it used to be.
Cheers amigo........... [ Reply to This ]
distortion &mdash 12/03/06 - 11:23:53 AM
Except for that 'bump' just before the start of the first chorus, I don't hear distortion in the vocal track. I'll try to listen close again... Thanks a million for pointing this out and for your great comment.
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
you boys rock my socks &mdash 12/03/06 - 12:19:49 AM
That's it. Walter, you're now my favorite male vocalist here at MacJams. Gawd, I love the tremelo in your voice at the end of the phrases. And the bass notes.... yummy. This is the real deal.
And Shawn (is it Sean?), your music is f'ing brilliant as usual. Sorry, I'm getting carried away. This is just too good.
You boys rock. Thank you for finding each other. Can I borrow Walter for some vocals, though? :-) [ Reply to This ]
carried away by your visit &mdash 12/03/06 - 11:40:53 AM
Wow... your favourite male vocalist? You're too kind, Miss C! But you're right about this: Shawn is indeed a f'king brilliant composer, musician and orchestrator. And I cherish this collab project like a baby. Borrow me? Hmmm... let me check the current rates... :-) With pleasure of course.
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
Love it &mdash 12/03/06 - 04:32:40 AM
thx Kanta... &mdash 12/03/06 - 11:46:36 AM
... for always being so supportive. Very much appreciated.
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
Walter .... &mdash 12/03/06 - 04:38:05 AM
.. I was both shocked and stunned by your vocals on this one .... I was expecting to hear that deeeeeeeeep BASSSSSS resonance that I have come to expect .... I now know your range travels ... in both directions .... very NICE !!!!! [ Reply to This ]
Alannah... &mdash 12/03/06 - 12:38:54 PM
Perhaps I just might want to get rid of the 'lowest voice of MJ' reputation :-) No, I guess Shawn's basic composition was so damned rich that it allowed me to use the full vocal scale. Thanks for stopping by, Alannah. You're always a welcome guest.
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
perfect couple &mdash 12/03/06 - 05:50:11 AM
Walter, Shawn...you are a perfect musically couple...the inspiration of each others donation is listenable and makes it a joy for the listener. I like this track a lot. The lyrics are a invitation to enter yesteryears world.Thanlk you both for taking me to this place.
I am like always looking forward for your next one. I am sure Shawn is allready buisy with it... [ Reply to This ]
perfect friend &mdash 12/03/06 - 12:45:47 PM
A pleasure to bring you into the yesteryears' world, Tan. And a big thanks for your ever so lovely comments. You're right about the fact that Shawn is already busy with a new track. Be sure I'll keep you posted on this :-)
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
well &mdash 12/03/06 - 09:10:45 AM
crafted song....from the emotional vocals to the tight arrangement......u have a fan here.....! [ Reply to This ]
McBoy... &mdash 12/03/06 - 01:21:42 PM
Thanks, man. And a warm welcome to the PE-fanclub :-) And from my side I need to dive into the 'slingers' collab song soon again. I'll keep you posted...
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
Whoaa ! &mdash 12/03/06 - 11:31:40 AM
What a voice ! Beautiful song. Deep and magnificently crafed. Bravo les gars. [ Reply to This ]
thanks &mdash 12/03/06 - 01:33:39 PM
Un tout grand merci pour l'écoute et les commentaires, Youra!
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
fantastic new trick &mdash 12/03/06 - 12:30:23 PM
what a pleasure to hear such a magnificient track, what a trick! perfect combination of everything. you guys should plan a live event at some stage :) [ Reply to This ]
Fred! &mdash 12/03/06 - 01:38:12 PM
Merci Fred, I value your comments a lot. And let me tell you again that I enjoyed our recent tri-collab so much as well. Will be continued very soon...
A live gig? Brilliant idea!
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
Good collab... &mdash 12/03/06 - 04:05:14 PM
As always a very good work Walter and your collab with Shawn give a succesful result.
Your voice is perfectly in harmony with the music sounds.
I like really this track and I think that your style is unique here. Bravo...
Marc
[ Reply to This ]
merci Marc &mdash 12/05/06 - 01:13:33 PM
Thanks a bunch for your support, neighbour! Heartwarming.
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
creative &mdash 12/03/06 - 07:20:56 PM
i like the opening instrumental. some crazy sounding guitar. an interesting vocal, it's sort of haunting and dark in some parts. at points it kind of reminds me of the smiths. creative lyrics. like the mellow part near the end. [ Reply to This ]
the smiths &mdash 12/05/06 - 01:17:31 PM
It's always interesting to hear about those comparisons. The smiths never came to my mind, but I think I can see what you mean. Thanks for your time listening and commenting, Chance.
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
damn ! &mdash 12/04/06 - 12:44:33 AM
The stuff you guys do together is particularly perfect. This one reminds me of Japan, or maybe Sisters of Mercy... but perhaps cooler than both? Seriously. [ Reply to This ]
Japan &mdash 12/05/06 - 01:24:57 PM
Damn, for once I was so happy not be compared with David Sylvian again... and there comes Japan... Haha, don't worry, this is a real honour. Thanks so much for your comment, Eric.
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
Blown away &mdash 12/04/06 - 07:33:30 AM
Thanks K &mdash 12/05/06 - 01:47:03 PM
Blown away by your artistry as well. Maybe you should join us for a PE track some day.
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
Yesteryears &mdash 12/04/06 - 02:52:26 PM
I probably shouldn't be commenting because I don't really understand this kind of music. I did find it interesting from an orchestration standpoint...but I wonder what the point of having lyrics is if the listener can't understand them on their own?! You are definitely quite a talented poet and have a message to tell. But the song doesn't do it...for me.
Paul [ Reply to This ]
Confused &mdash 12/05/06 - 01:55:21 PM
I'm confused here, Paul, and maybe you could help me out. I've read your comment at least 10 times, but still don't quite get what you mean. Are the lyrics too abstract, or do you want to say you don't hear them through the music? You kind of like the orchestration, but the song doesn't work for you. Hmmm, really I would like you to explain me more in detail what bothers you about the song. Is it the genre? In that case I can't do much. Hey, I don't like for instance country music, so I will never comment on it, just because I cannot judge in that case whether song is good or bad. Or do you think it's bad in its genre? In that case, please explain. I'm always open and anxious to learn. One of the main reasons why I joined this community...
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
then don't listen. &mdash 12/05/06 - 04:41:34 PM
sorry. but i listened to your music Paul. you play with the finesse of some of the finest players i schooled with at peabody(i'm a classical guitarist)...... such nice phrasing and semi - virtuostic technique..... in a traditional sense.......but there are many of us out there making music that doesn't conform to older traditional arranging and performance...... you can't understand the lyrics without them printed? then make your own to it with your imagination..... there is nothing constructive about your comment.............many apollogies for this. although you are a skilled musician..... it's too bad you don't have the frame of mind to come out of your conservatory snobbery...... [ Reply to This ]
HMMM &mdash 12/04/06 - 05:54:03 PM
Old farts need not apply! This was cool! SOunded really professional! I like your vocal slager! [ Reply to This ]
A great tune - but ..) &mdash 12/04/06 - 05:54:36 PM
As I told Walter before I 'd like to hear more of Shawn's great sounds :)
He promised me to do another collaboration with Shawn where he will keep this in mind.
I like Walter's voice - no doubt - but it is too present her (IMHO).
Waiting impatiently for the next tune :) [ Reply to This ]
promised &mdash 12/05/06 - 03:30:30 PM
Next time I'll keep my addition to some minor 'ooohs' and 'aaahs'. Hehe...
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
Synthesis &mdash 12/04/06 - 05:59:15 PM
David... &mdash 12/05/06 - 03:36:16 PM
I always welcome your thoughts and comments.
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
Superb collab - congratulations! &mdash 12/05/06 - 03:35:19 AM
Incredible collab guys!! Shawn's instrumentation is exceptional (and rather inspiring). Walter, great vocalising as usual. I especially enjoyed the guitar work on this - not overpowering but strong and aggressive nonetheless. I'd probably like to hear more of Walter in the loud sections and a little less in the softer passages. Hey Biz, I'm an old fart and I love this stuff!
Neil [ Reply to This ]
collab &mdash 12/05/06 - 03:59:11 PM
Neil, believe me... working together with this hyper-talented guy is nothing less than a dream come true. Not easy to keep pace with his great artistry. As always, I value your comment a lot, and I completely understand what you mean. Hey, you're everything but an old fart to me (Chad replied more or less to Paul's comment, well... you're certainly aware of his 'direct' communication style:-)
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
Apparently... &mdash 12/06/06 - 07:25:27 AM
I thought I'd left a comment a few days ago, but apparently not. Anyway, the gist of it is: Very impressive. I love all the musical touches; lots of "ear candy" to keep a person constantly interested. And the singing is as always, haunting, moving, impressive. Great job here! [ Reply to This ]
ear candy &mdash 12/06/06 - 03:36:08 PM
Clark, your comments always mean a lot to me. As a classical musician/composer, you are man with a broad and open vision. I like that a lot.
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
An impressive... &mdash 12/06/06 - 02:51:37 PM
almost scary tune. The guitar arrangements are beautiful, as is the vocal. Walter, in the lower registers your voice shines. One rarely sees vocals this low in Rock/Pop. The only singer I remember that goes so low was the guy from Type O Negative. But I like this work (much) better. If I heard this on the radio, I probably wouldn't recognize it for not being a full studio production. I wouldn't zap away either. Great work, both of you.
Best
Denny [ Reply to This ]
don't zap away:-) &mdash 12/07/06 - 04:56:41 PM
Thanks Denny for these beautiful comments. I really dig your last tune as well, even if I'm lousy in solving that damned puzzle... A great and very creative idea by the way.
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
One of the coolest... &mdash 12/07/06 - 05:42:53 PM
voices at Macjams singing on darkly cool music soundbed. Great team effort here. A mood rock-piece that really does harken back to Bowie. This is really unique, different and yet immediately likable. Kudos [ Reply to This ]
'different and yet immediately likable'... &mdash 12/09/06 - 06:38:10 AM
...that's one hell of a compliment, and exactly what we intend to reach with Particulate Eden: trying to walk on the thin line of a kind of semi-meanstream genre. Listenable but surely out of the common. I'm very happy with that. And of course a reference to Mr Bowie is ALWAYS welcomed :-)
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
wow &mdash 12/07/06 - 09:31:23 PM
really cuts. walter your vocals continue to blow me away. your ability to collab with so many diverse artists is impressive as h*ll.
atonalis : brilliant. the theatrical souring guitars to the deliberate and beautiful piano interludes. this is a stunning track. very trippy. [ Reply to This ]
spoiling &mdash 12/09/06 - 06:32:15 AM
John, you're spoiling me/us with such great comments. Thanks for stopping by and taking your time to listen. Very much appreciated.
- Walter
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
... &mdash 12/08/06 - 07:30:31 PM
euh... &mdash 12/09/06 - 06:30:00 AM
...is that a problem?
---
Logic takes you from a to b. Imagination takes you everywhere. [ Reply to This ]
Epic... &mdash 12/13/06 - 06:57:52 PM
Well, we know it's not "Cronkite"... It's sure you can deliver the latest news in great music... This is very complete with all of the combined elements reporting in to complete the Headline. Great job! . - Harold [ Reply to This ]
this to to the &mdash 12/23/06 - 11:19:42 PM
Very nice you guys! I'm glad I stopped in and found this to listen to and DL. Excellent all the way around... music, lyrics, vocals, production... Cheers! [ Reply to This ]
very cool ! &mdash 12/27/06 - 05:56:41 PM
When it started I thought that it was going in one direction, and before I know it, it's gone in a completely different direction. Definitely loved the composition, and the vocals were spot on. They've got a nice "dark" feel to them which was really cool. GREAT colab ! [ Reply to This ]
Grabbed me... &mdash 12/27/06 - 06:29:25 PM
...and held me tight. From the opening guitar line in the intro and to the final bitcrushed beats at the very end, I was listening closely.
Your voice has something about it that's very alluring and pleasant to listen to. I don't know what it is, but it's good. And it fits very well with the overall vibe of the track.
Which brings me to the mix/production. Not much to say about that. How can one criticize something that does not need criticizing?
"If it ain't broke, don't fix it!"
A great collaboration and a very cool track.
-Einar S. [ Reply to This ]
thoughts from the bull... &mdash 01/19/07 - 12:57:34 AM
came across this one in the 2006 MacJams Retrospective collection. such a deeply interesting and evocative piece. walter, i didn't realize this was something you had done, so i hope you know how joyed i was to realize this!
like most everything else you've done, the piece draws the listener in like blurred words written on a stone. your work is theatrical and dynamic, conjuring epic images and grand scapes. you've both created something wonderful here. nice work!
nothing about this that i didn't enjoy. i'm happy i get to play it as much as i want! thank you, as always! [ Reply to This ]
Awesome! &mdash 02/18/07 - 03:03:38 PM
As leaves one in awe. Lyrics are very deep, as in i read them quite thoroughly and still can't grasp them entirely, it is a sad song. That much i do understand. Two points of very subjective criticism in the greek sense of word (kritikos=positive:-)), 1 the lyrics are sung too fast in the beginning, like your trying to catch up, 2 the percussion lacks velocity changes. For example the closed hi-hats roll in the latter part of the song have the same velocity, it gives me a on off on binary feel. I noticed since i have that problem a lot, you get that when playing drums on a computer, it just lacks natural velocity differences and other influences.
BUT!
My hat goes off to you two and I bow in awe!
See the criticism as jealousy or a compared to the other comments not too gentle push towards perfection (as if i know what it is).
[ Reply to This ]
hey marc.. &mdash 02/19/07 - 03:05:23 PM
You're right about the vocals! In the first verse they come just a tiny bit too early in the mix, which gives that feeling as if they are 'running in front' of the music. Just one of those little things that can happen with collab songs, especially one like this, where Shawn and I work on completely incompattible platforms.
About the velocity changes... I don't know anything about that. So I give you the advantage of the doubt :-)
Thanks so much again for taking your time to listen and comment. Be sure this is very much appreciated, especially when it's done with a critical ear like yours.
- Walter [ Reply to This ]
Im glad to hear &mdash 02/20/07 - 04:21:54 AM
Justs after i had hit the submit button i was like, oh oh Marc, wasn't there another way of putting it?. No (giving time constraints in this stressed body). I dont want to sweet talk no one any more and wouldn't give these comments if i really didn't like the song. Bladiblabla, you know that. Your voice, sigh...the beats (atonalis is a true magician of the sorts)
It rocks the dogs b4llocks (as the Brits eloquently put it). Phew. And I know how difficult it is to collab over these distances. Keep em comming sir!!!
yours truly
---
if you don't succeed at first skydiving is not for you [ Reply to This ]
Brilliant! &mdash 02/20/07 - 08:18:15 PM
I have been rendered nearly speechless by this... I had no idea that the two of you had paired off to collab in this way - Feeling a little stupid...
Excellent combo, and on all accounts - Words can only diminish what I hear in this -
Thanks fellows! Macca [ Reply to This ]
feel stupid? &mdash 02/21/07 - 01:18:19 PM
No reason to feel stupid, macca! Your visit is much much appreciated. As are your lovely words.
- Walter [ Reply to This ]
Split &mdash 06/10/07 - 06:31:27 PM
I like the music quite a bit. The glitchy drums with the piano and guitar is nicely mixed.
And Walter's voice is so unique and grabbing. It fits well in this song.
However, I feel like the vocals and the music are fighting each other throughout this piece. I don't get a feeling of interplay between the music and the vox. There is still quite a bit of promise in this one, though.
-g [ Reply to This ]
Great! &mdash 06/07/08 - 02:33:56 AM
Not my usual style but I find this a masterpiece... KUDOS guys, amazing tune!
Take Care
- Yeman A. Al-Rawi [ Reply to This ]
|
[ Reply to This ]