Home Community Music Blog Old MJ More...      
The Same But Different by dolby [Email]

Get Flash to see this player.


Having playback trouble, try the Quicktime player:

Attribution-NoDerivs-NonCommercial
SONG STATS:
Hits: 1082
Comments: 49
Votes: 13
Plays: 225
Last Played: Oct 15, 2008 - 07:59:17 AM
Downloads: 58
Fans: 23
Uploaded: Sep 21, 2007 - 04:23:04 AM
Last Updated: Sep 21, 2007 - 11:06:21 PM
Fan List
Keywords:
Cambodia (1), Travel (23), Same (11), Bangkok (1), Asia (23)
Description:
The Same But Different

This is the closing track from my forthcoming CD "Where Are We Now?" which will be released on TLR in December.

The following story is quite long, so feel free to skip it - but if you want to know more about this song, then read on:

CAMBODIA 2007
Firstly I need to introduce you to the concept of *Same Same*. If you ever spend any time in South East Asia (Thailand, Laos, Vietnam, Cambodia) you will see people wearing t-shirts with "Same Same" written on the front, and "But Different" written on the back. This comes from the many stall holders, and souvenir sellers in the area who will try and sell you anything for a dollar. Bartering is always a lengthy & protracted experience in these parts, but has to be done. So when you explain to the vendor that you can get the same item he's selling for half the price down the road, the stall holder will tell you to ignore this fact because what *he* is trying to sell you is different - while at the same time being exactly the same!

When you try to explain that this just doesn't make any sense the stall holder will inevitably just nod, smile and repeat that it's all just "Same Same, But Different."

I LOVE THIS IDEA, and for me these four words sum up the Indochina experience: slightly desperate, nonsensical and endearingly funny at the same time.

When this song started to come together it made sense to relate this idea to a bigger picture: that we are all very different, but at the end of the day pretty much the same, with similar hopes and fears, and definitely the same needs, wants and desires. In Bangkok this was exemplified by seeing a monk in a temple talking on his brand new Nokia phone - the ancient and the modern coming together; just 'cos you're a monk doesn't mean you can't have the best cell on the market!

The verses of the song really started to take shape as we travelled through Cambodia, visiting places like Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum and the notorious Killing Fields. You soon realise that Cambodia has a wretched history of tragedy and destruction, and is still living with corruption and violence on a massive scale. So, in verse two I am sitting in the roof-top bar of the Foreign Correspondents Club in Phnom Penh (where journalists drank as they reported on the war) reflecting on how, despite all this mess, the people of Cambodia are some of the warmest, friendliest and most positive people you could ever wish to meet. Something which is at the same time incomprehensible, amazing and life-affirming.

Cambodia had a profound effect on me, and has stayed with me since I returned to the *civilised* west. The one thing that struck me above all else is how life in Cambodia, and elsewhere in Indochina, is hard. Yet the people there just 'get on with it'. This was highlighted to me as we travelled from Siem Reap to the Thai border along the 'main' highway - which is little more than a muddy track. It started to rain torrentially and suddenly this mud track became a quagmire. Lorries, cars and bikes were skidding all over the place, getting stuck or sliding off the track into fields and ditches. Then, just as we were beginning to realise that making progress was hopeless and dangerous, out of the window of our stationary bus I saw a man on a moped ride past with a pig strapped to the back of his bike (that's him in the photo above). He was obviously off to market, and a little bit of mud and rain wasn't going to stop him.

I couldn't help but feel for this man who was battling the odds because, well, he had no choice. I thought that if that was me I'd just quit and go home, put my feet up, watch some TV. But he didn't have the option to do that - he had a pig to sell. An hour or so later, after we'd turned around and were heading back to Siem Reap we passed this man again, only now he was at the side of the road repairing a puncture! Nothing like kicking a man when he's down, I thought. The thing is, this is what life is like - not occasionally - but all the time, for millions of people all over the world. It makes you think....

So the final verse is a simple reflection: when you think your life is shit, just stop for a minute and remember that somewhere in the world there'll be some poor bugger on a bike in the pissing rain trying to get a pig to market. It's not a new idea, I know, but I don't know whether it's been expressed in such a way before....

So there you have it. It's an unashamed, lighters in the air album closer with a big finale and a minor key refrain that might just tickle your spine. I hope you like it.

Thanks for reading this if you've made it to the end -
Cheers,
Phil

Lyrics:
The Same But Different
(by Phil Dolby ©2007)

When you get lost on the open highway
And you think of the cost you’re not willing to pay
At a Buddha in Bangkok a Nokia tone
A monk on a mobile; a 3G cell phone
 
(chorus)
It’s all the same
It’s all the same, but different
It’s all the same
It’s all the same, but different
 
When you look down on a city landscape
At the far points of light going different ways
You’re a rooftop reporter with a digital feed
And a pixel distorter to control what is seen
 
(chorus)
It’s all the same
It’s all the same, but different
It’s all the same
It’s all the same, but different
 
It’s one of those things, an incalculable thing
But it’s driving me to distraction
We let it go on, even though it’s so wrong
Without ever a call to reaction
How can we sit while the people who work the land with their hands
Are broken and shattered
How can we sit while the people who work the land with their hands
Don’t seem to matter...
 
When you come home at the end of the day
And your energy’s gone and you’re fading away
There’s a man on a moped on a muddy highway
Going nowhere and slowly with a puncture delay
 
(chorus)
It’s all the same
It’s all the same, but different
It’s all the same
It’s all the same, but different
It’s all the same
It’s all the same, but different
It’s all the same
It’s all the same, but different

Hardware:
Hohner acoustic guitar

Software:
GB
You must be registered and logged-in to comment.

Very Heartfelt ! &mdash 09/21/07 - 04:31:40 AM
Phil this is just great song, the guitar sounds great and really clear to my ears, the vocal at the best level.
Good Luck with your CD friend ! this is great piece
Kudos !

Take Care
- Yeman A. Al-Rawi

[ Reply to This ]
The Same But Different &mdash 09/21/07 - 07:12:07 AM
very much agree here with you ..thank you for sharin
the story ,very thoughtfull song .and singin just so
respectfull .sure one of your best ,and I wish to take
the chance and wish you all the luck with your Comin
CD .. KUDOS !!

[ Reply to This ]
travel journals &mdash 09/21/07 - 07:17:02 AM
I love the lengthy reports you give on your songs. It would be great if your cd came with your travel journal or notes like these.

Anyway, this is a great song. I agree with Yeman the guitars are clear and compelling.

It wouldn't hurt if your voice came out a little more, too :)

I like how the song builds, the brassy synths add great counterpoint.

[ Reply to This ]
Thanks Estella &mdash 09/26/07 - 05:34:27 AM
This will be the last of the 'long' travelogues - as I've finished my travel songs now, but I am writing a travel book - so if it ever gets published I'll let you know :-)


---
Same Same, But Different

[ Reply to This ]
great tune &mdash 09/21/07 - 07:27:00 AM
i liked it beginning to end. vocals, lyrics, dynamics everything! great piece. luck with the cd!

[ Reply to This ]
Extremely &mdash 09/21/07 - 07:32:30 AM
well written, played, sung and constructed song - great prodcution.
Cheers
Len



[ Reply to This ]
Love it &mdash 09/21/07 - 07:49:11 AM
Very good song... Production is outstanding. Kudos.
Thx for sharing... a D-load for sure.

Kenta

[ Reply to This ]
great &mdash 09/21/07 - 07:53:14 AM
Glad you prompted us all to have a listen to this - cos I really liked it. Reminded me a little of Pink Floyd in the animals/the wall period with that scything guitar and vocal delivery. That's a compliment by the way, in case you hate prog! I will check out your back catalogue when I have a chance. Good luck with the cd too!

[ Reply to This ]
Cheers Smokey Bacon &mdash 09/26/07 - 05:36:48 AM
No worries about Floyd comparisons (or prog for that matter). I'm pretty much locked into The Final Cut as my template and there's a deffo bit of that in here.

Glad you approve :-)

---
Same Same, But Different

[ Reply to This ]
Really Terrific &mdash 09/21/07 - 10:40:53 AM
I am not sure I have read any better lyrics here at MJ.
Thanks for such a THOUGHT provoking song.

What great analogies in the contrasting cultures. And the music really backs up the nice singin and backround sounds.

Way to go!



[ Reply to This ]
Thanks Bill &mdash 09/26/07 - 05:39:00 AM
That's a real compliment about the lyrics. There are alot of great wordsmiths on this site, so I'm glad you approve.

Appreciate you dropping bye -

Cheers
Phil

---
Same Same, But Different

[ Reply to This ]
ya &mdash 09/21/07 - 11:36:11 AM
your right ...without manipulating the camera you can never duplicate what is seen ...cause there is so much more than just sight !

[ Reply to This ]
YES &mdash 09/21/07 - 02:12:15 PM
A really nice song .. composition, performance and arrangment!

Thank you for pointing it out!

Johannes Curry


[ Reply to This ]
Thanks Johannes &mdash 09/26/07 - 05:41:15 AM
Glad you found the song and enjoyed - appreciate it

---
Same Same, But Different

[ Reply to This ]
Same old same &mdash 09/21/07 - 06:30:39 PM
Love it! I think the vocal needs to be louder and since it's the last song on the CD, I think you might want to revisit this.
I like the concept of same same, and was sort of hoping the chorus had that phrase in it, since "it's all the same" as a phrase is a little overused, but that's okay, since what you came up with fits so well into the meter of the melody.

[ Reply to This ]
You lost your hat! &mdash 09/21/07 - 11:47:25 PM
Another great song with an outstanding production. I can relate to the lyrics pretty well. I often wonder why I seldom post new ones and I came to the conclusion that I'm spending to much time listening and commenting on yours ;-P Nice work indeed Mr. Dolby

Ax



[ Reply to This ]
I love... &mdash 09/22/07 - 01:51:16 AM
... the lyrics and observations... the 3G cell phone, and the chorus says it all its a small planet after all! Great work phil

steve

[ Reply to This ]
Good song &mdash 09/22/07 - 11:29:31 AM
coupled with rock steady production - excellent all round.

Peter

[ Reply to This ]
Thanks Peter &mdash 09/26/07 - 05:42:38 AM
Glad you found the song and approve - cheers

---
Same Same, But Different

[ Reply to This ]
very cool &mdash 09/23/07 - 09:44:09 AM
I like your description must be a whole different world1 I feel bad for the guy with the pig all that and a flat. Its the same but for us different . A nice moving and well mixed song I enjoyed this one alot!

[ Reply to This ]
Cheers Egobandit &mdash 09/26/07 - 05:44:57 AM
Yep, it is a whole different world - sometimes we forget, and sometimes we need reminding. Thanks for dropping by - appreciate it

---
Same Same, But Different

[ Reply to This ]
A Poetic Look Beyond &mdash 09/23/07 - 02:39:47 PM
...the world we live in, lost in our entertaining-ourselves-to-oblivion society where "life and death" means how well our stock portfolios are doing. You're quite right about the idea not being new, but every idea we express becomes new, becomes ours, and adds its particular resonance to the music of the world. It's the same... but different.

Beautiful song, with strong bones and a deceptively gentle touch that haunts. In this particular subject area it's easy to beat the listener with maudlin images and sorry words; good intentions and an 800-number running across the bottom of the screen, et all. But this is just a ride in a bus on a muddy road in a place we can barely imagine, where countless others live their lives every day - living lives as real and important as ours.

The same... but different.

[ Reply to This ]
Thanks Rik &mdash 09/26/07 - 05:48:24 AM
Now that is a proper review - thanks very much. All comments should be as thoughtful as this....

I'm blown away!

---
Same Same, But Different

[ Reply to This ]
really nice tune Phil &mdash 09/25/07 - 10:18:04 PM
Different is good, right?

A cool Floydian flavor. A bit of wish you where here gone electric.

Does make for a good closing tune for a CD. Kind of sums up life. Great build for the finish.

Now is this going to be a concept album? There's a story there




[ Reply to This ]
Thanks Vic &mdash 09/26/07 - 05:51:08 AM
Not a concept album - but a series of songs linked together by a common theme......

......which you could describe as a concept album....

...oh my god, call the cops, this is illegal isn't it?

---
Same Same, But Different

[ Reply to This ]
Sublime! &mdash 10/07/07 - 12:28:49 AM
I love everything about this piece brother. Pink Floyd and Beatle influences abound...(a compliment!) Well written. Well played. Well sung...BRAVO!

Be well!

[ Reply to This ]
same-same &mdash 10/19/07 - 06:52:00 AM
but different comment.I just about made it to the end of your description - I've become a very lazy reader of late.Its a great observation and ideal songwriting material and you have done a really good job on this song with all the intertwining melodies and themes coming from quite a straightforward chord structure.I haven't travelled the world at all but I have come to the belief that in order to get some kind of understanding of what its like to be the poor bugger with the pig you have to live without luxury and then pretty soon the things that were once non-significant become a luxury.A cheap second hand transistor radio that cost 3 from a junk stall became a lifeline when I was travelling and busking.I chose that life though and these people probably dont have that choice.

Excellent theme,and song - RG

[ Reply to This ]
Thanks again... &mdash 10/21/07 - 10:39:30 PM
...Richard.

Yes, travelling through certain parts of the world is a real eye opener, and does make you appreciate what you've got.

Glad you at least had a go at reading the blurb :-))

Thanks for the comment -
Phil

[ Reply to This ]
Like Your Style &mdash 10/26/07 - 10:07:22 AM
Phil

I really like your musical style. This is a great song to end a CD with. Love the music and lyrics. The only avice I would give is the vocals seem to loud in the mix. I would pull them in a little.

Cheers,

Ed

[ Reply to This ]
sorry &mdash 10/26/07 - 10:12:08 AM
Take it back vocals are spot on after second listen.

[ Reply to This ]
Nice &mdash 11/10/07 - 07:55:03 AM
I like the slow driving beat and the horns at the end. Chorus works well :)

Thanks
Bill

[ Reply to This ]
Fantastic! &mdash 11/15/07 - 07:52:09 PM
A great song!

H

[ Reply to This ]
Outstanding &mdash 11/29/07 - 03:14:08 PM
Firstly the music - I like this. It grooves along nicely enough until that bridge makes you sit up straight. I love the ethnic sounding instrument in the final refrain. The vocal delivery is superb (like Michael Stipe when he still remembered how to smile.)

But what blows me away is the imagery. It's witty and sharp, but also poignant in its depiction of the man with a mission on a bike. You have woven your experience and acute observation into a song, and you communicate it brilliantly.

Outstanding songwriting and performance.

MacFerret

[ Reply to This ]
Flippin' heck... &mdash 12/03/07 - 07:44:05 AM
MacFerret, now that's a review!!! Thankyou so much. Glad you enjoyed the track -

Cheers,
Phil

[ Reply to This ]
review TAIL &mdash 12/04/07 - 07:04:20 PM
First up, the sound is incredibly good. The space and tone and definition is spot on. Well done. I would have mixed it a little differently to disentangle the major parts, but of course that's a matter of style taste.

The song itself is very enjoyable and engaging. Do you play all the parts?

I've never been to the Far East but I can imagine that they also have x-boxes, sub-prime credit crunch issues and bird flu. So very different...!

Nicely done

Chas

[ Reply to This ]
Thanks Sir Dennis &mdash 12/09/07 - 10:21:15 AM
Yes, I do play all the parts - just me and an acoustic guitar and a MacBook laptop.

Given my time again, and a decent recording studio, proper musicians and a decent vocal mic I agree that I probably would mix it differently myself:-)) As with all my other songs on here this was recorded pretty much in one take, without much editing and mixed on headphones. The version on the upcoming CD has the vox mixed a little higher and generally a bit more bite in the mix.

Glad you liked the tune. Thanks for the comment -
Phil

[ Reply to This ]
laid back &mdash 12/17/07 - 06:15:41 PM
way back...cool voice you have....dig the acoustic and electric tones....nice work....clean mix....kudos to you amigo....peace

[ Reply to This ]
Thanks... &mdash 01/03/08 - 07:23:00 AM
...freefalleffect. Sorry it's taken so long to reply - hadn't noticed that anyone had called in for a while, so cheers!

[ Reply to This ]
Sentiment &mdash 01/03/08 - 01:44:53 AM
Sorry it took me so long to get here, Phil. I think the sentiment expressed in this phone is awesome. I feel exactly the same. The arrangement and chord progressions are excellent. The only thing I would suggest is that the bass guitar seems a little low in the mix except in the last chorus--it sees to come up a bit. A great anthem. Well done.
Philip

[ Reply to This ]
Hey... &mdash 01/03/08 - 07:27:59 AM
...thanks Philip. Yeah, pretty much agree about the bass. It's one of those where my natural instinct is to push the bass and hold off the vocal, but through much trial and error in this song I was encouraged to push the vocal, and I think the bass got forgotten about en route!

This is the last track on my CD and Jim Bouchard had mastered the songs and brought out some missing sounds throughout - so maybe the bass comes back a little.

Thanks for the comment, appreciated as always -

Phil

[ Reply to This ]
Fantastic. &mdash 04/03/08 - 06:22:05 AM
Hi
Oh my goodness this had me swooning with your very sweet and sexy Voice that tell a very nice worldly story and brilliant lyrics,great singing and guitar playng loved it all. I will be downloading this. Thank you for sharing your wonderful song.
Peace Dee.

[ Reply to This ]
Ooh flipping heck... &mdash 06/24/08 - 09:57:33 AM
...thanks Dee - sorry for being so late in replying:-)) But thanks for the listen. Never been told my voice was sexy before. Nice one :-))

[ Reply to This ]
Loved the story behind the song &mdash 06/24/08 - 09:13:55 AM
and the song itself is wonderful. Really well performed and produced. The arrangement has just the right balance of intimacy and universality - not too grand yet powerful. Well done - glad I stopped by.

[ Reply to This ]
Cheers Bud &mdash 06/24/08 - 09:50:52 AM
Thanks. Been away from MJ's for a while, but glad to be back. Looking forward to hearing some good music and getting some new stuff online. Thanks for the comment. It's been a while since I had one :-))

[ Reply to This ]
I &mdash 06/29/08 - 03:19:21 PM
really like this song Phil, so well produced and great sounds from all the instruments!
Love the guitars and a great vocal!
Thanks!

[ Reply to This ]
Hey Bob &mdash 07/01/08 - 04:46:09 AM
Thanks for another visit. Yep, I've always been pretty happy with this one. Glad you liked it. Cheers.

[ Reply to This ]
Thank you &mdash 07/03/08 - 12:22:08 PM
The song is outstanding and the story made it all the more powerful. Thank you for your visit I may not have found this gem otherwise.

[ Reply to This ]
never made it &mdash 07/05/08 - 10:16:04 AM
there, but this take me there. I've seen what you sing about. great lyrics and lovely voice to sing it. Cheers phil.

[ Reply to This ]
inspiration &mdash 07/20/08 - 07:53:47 AM
its guess its funny where we draw inspiration from to make music. and your inspiration came from a different place and this added to the flavour of the song. great lyrics and great feel. there was this kinds optimistic overtone that i picked up on even though it was a little down. you cam from the right place when writing this song

[ Reply to This ]
Copyright 2008 Simig Media, Inc.